The Finance Talent Paradox: Why Good Candidates Are Getting Harder to Find

Eibhleann Corbett | Finance Recruitment Consultant

Across the finance market, businesses are looking for increasingly specific skill sets, while experienced candidates are becoming more selective about their next career move. The result is a growing disconnect between what employers want and what the available talent pool can realistically offer.

Recruiting finance professionals has become increasingly complex. While organisations continue to seek individuals with strong technical knowledge, relevant qualifications and industry experience, the expectations placed on finance teams are evolving. Professionals are now expected to bring commercial awareness, technological capability and the confidence to influence wider business decisions.

For employers across the Irish market, this presents a familiar challenge: why is finding the right finance talent becoming so difficult, even when there are candidates actively looking for opportunities?

The answer is not simply a shortage of accountants. It is a combination of changing skill requirements, candidate expectations and a growing gap between employer wish lists and the realities of the recruitment market.

The Changing Demands on Finance Professionals

Finance roles have evolved considerably. Traditionally, technical accounting expertise, professional qualifications and relevant sector experience were the primary considerations when recruiting. While these remain fundamental, businesses increasingly want finance professionals who can offer much more.

The growth of automation, data analytics and AI is changing how finance teams operate. Employers are looking for individuals who can interpret financial information, support forecasting, identify commercial opportunities and contribute to strategic decision-making. Technical ability is still essential, but communication, problem-solving and business partnering skills are becoming equally valuable.

This creates additional pressure within the wider Irish market, where organisations across professional services, manufacturing, financial services and industry are competing for experienced finance talent. The challenge is finding candidates who combine the right technical foundations with the broader commercial capabilities businesses now expect.

Candidate Expectations Are Changing

The other side of the equation is candidate mobility. Finance professionals are increasingly considering more than salary when deciding whether to move roles.

Career progression, flexibility, company culture, management style and opportunities to develop are all influencing decisions. Hybrid working remains an important consideration, while many candidates are also looking for roles that offer greater responsibility and exposure to commercial decision-making.

For employers, this means that an attractive salary package alone may not be enough to secure the strongest candidates. Those who can demonstrate clear progression opportunities, supportive leadership and a positive working environment are often better positioned to attract and retain talent.

There is also a growing challenge around timing. Good finance professionals, particularly those with specialist experience or professional qualifications, are rarely available for long. In a competitive market, employers who take too long to make decisions risk losing strong candidates to organisations that can move more quickly.

The Disconnect Between Expectations and Reality

One of the biggest challenges in finance recruitment is the gap between an employer’s ideal candidate and what the market can realistically supply.

It is understandable that businesses want someone who ticks every box. However, when a role requires a particular qualification, extensive sector experience, specialist systems knowledge, commercial exposure and a salary expectation that does not reflect the market, the available talent pool can become very limited.

This is particularly relevant for mid-level and senior finance appointments, where employers are often looking for a combination of technical expertise and proven leadership capability.

Sometimes, the strongest candidate may not have every requirement listed in the job specification, but they could bring the potential, transferable experience and commercial understanding to make a significant contribution.

Being too restrictive can mean overlooking excellent professionals who could add real value to the organisation.

What This Means for Employers

For businesses looking to strengthen their finance teams, the key is understanding where flexibility is possible and where it is not. Reviewing job specifications, benchmarking salaries and considering transferable skills can all help broaden the available talent pool.

This is also where a strong recruitment partnership becomes particularly valuable. An experienced finance recruitment consultant understands the market from both sides, including current candidate availability, salary expectations and what motivates professionals to consider a move.

When a consultant recommends considering a candidate outside the original brief, or highlights that the salary attached to a role may need reviewing, it is worth understanding the reasoning behind that advice. It is not simply about changing the brief; it is informed by ongoing market conversations, recruitment experience and an understanding of what is realistically achievable.

The most successful recruitment outcomes come when employers and consultants work collaboratively, combining a clear understanding of the business requirement with an honest view of the market.

Looking to strengthen your finance team?

Whether you are recruiting for a newly qualified accountant, an experienced finance professional or a senior finance appointment, understanding the market is essential to securing the right talent.

To discuss your finance recruitment requirements and how we can help you navigate the current candidate market, contact a member of our Finance Team at Artemis Human Capital.

E: info@artemis-humancapital.com